Where
does one kind of music end and another begin?
How much do we invest in the distinctions
between genres, when the differences between
them may not be that great? Someone famously
said, "There are only two kinds of
music, good and bad." That the quote
has been attributed to musicians as varied
in their backgrounds as Duke Ellington and
Richard Strauss attests to its basis in
fact: Musicians make music from the language
at hand. Genre has nothing to do with it.
That
said, what shall we make of symphonic Led
Zeppelin? The Phoenix Symphony has been
hired on as the back‑up band for an
event Jan. 20 called "The Music of
Led Zeppelin: A Rock Symphony," to
be performed at the Dodge Theatre. (For
tickets, go to www.livenation.com or call
(480) 784‑4444.)
Usually,
when rock or contemporary pop tunes get
strings added, the result is denigrated
as Muzak. I've seen grown women freak out
when they notice a Duran Duran song or something
by Depeche Mode blurted out by stuttering
violins over the elevator. "When I
hear that music between floors," one
told me, "I know I'm old."
What
about when classic rock gets violins and
French horns and timpani and oboes? Does
it mean the music becomes classical?
"My
concept for The Music of Led Zeppelin was
to take the music as close to the originals
as we could and then add some colors to
enhance what Zep had done," says the
event's producer‑arranger Brent Havens
in a story posted at the Web site for station
KSLX (www.kslx.com).
"The
wonderful thing with an orchestra is that
you have an entire palette to call upon.
The band is reproducing what Led Zeppelin
did on the albums, verbatim, and then having
an orchestra behind the band gives the music
a richness, a whole different feel, a whole
different sense of power."
A
singer–Randy Jackson of rock band Zebra–will
sing Robert Plant's vocals while a band
duplicates Led Zeppelin's playing "riff
for riff." Havens will conduct the
symphony in its "enhancement."
The eighteen songs will include "Stairway
to Heaven," "Heartbreaker,"
"Black Dog" and "Immigrant
Song."
Music
is music, and can translate from rock to
symphonic without distortion, even if the
symphonic end of things is little more than
color added to an already full musical plate
of melody, harmony and rhythm. If those
basics are in place, the rest is a matter
of sonics, not of genre.
Ask
Nicole Pesce. The extravagantly gifted cocktail
pianist has more than 10,000 pieces of music
at her fingertips, and their variety staggers
the imagination.
One
night at My Florist, the downtown Phoenix
café where Pesce holds her court of chords
five nights a week, she started off with
a bouquet of Stevie Wonder songs that slid
into Henry Mancini's theme for "The
Pink Panther," sidled into Rodgers
and Hart's "This Can't Be Love,"
took a sharp turn into Warren Zevon's "Werewolves
of London," and ended with a big number
from the musical, "Les Miz." Somewhere
in there was a song by Coldplay.
She's
been known to segue from a Beatles medley
to Rachmaninoff to rags to Radiohead. If
a piece has melody‑harmony‑rhythm,
she can play it–which means, by the way,
that she can't play hip‑hop, because
it lacks the harmonic structure necessary
to bring it to the piano. For hip‑hop
to cross genres would require the percussion
section of a symphonic band. But it could
be done.
Music
in our time has had a lot to do with identity.
People who listen to country are different
from folks who listen to disco, who are
different from jazz, or classical, or world
music fans. Or so we're told. It has the
effect of prejudicing the unwitting against
a stranger, based on the music they like.
An earlier belief had it that music is a
universal language with the power to unite,
not divide. Listening to Pesce's phantasmagoria
of sound, the uniting idea would seem to
hold true.
Somewhere
in time is a music without labels, where
a piece is either one thing or another:
good or bad. But that's a distinction booby‑trapped
with its own prejudices and assumptions.
We'll go there another time–or not.