The Desert Advocate - News The Desert Advocate -  News Center
Editor | Links | Contact Us | Home
The Desert Advocate - Submissions
Classifieds | News | Events
News Real Estate Community Sports Marketplace Arts & Entertainment Archives About Us Testimonials Classifieds
  Weather >

Dear Craig,

I hope you can help me.  The other day I looked out to see a blue heron swallow one of my favorite Koi.  I ran outside and chased him away, but I know that he returned later on and helped himself to more of my prized fish.  I had some beautiful specimens, and many of them would eat right out of my hand.  I am so upset.  I would like to replenish my pond and save the fish that are left, but I’m afraid the heron will return and help himself again.  Is there anything I can do to protect my Koi? 

Ashley in Carefree

Dear Ashley,

Should you be thinking about some type of revenge, think again.  Herons are a protected species, so you can’t do anything that will harm them.  The same thing that attracts you to the Koi, their brilliant colors, also attracts the heron.  Our shallow ponds make it even easier for them to eat until they get their fill.  They can stand motionless beside the pond and wait for dinner to swim by or slowly walk through the water with their long legs, scattering the fish and threatening their hiding places. 

Herons aren’t the only predators that will eat the fish in your pond.  Considering that you live in Carefree, your pond is susceptible to even more predators, such as raccoons and bobcats.

However, I can sympathize with you.  I have a blue heron that frequents my backyard pond and an egret that snacks from the various ponds at the nursery.  Some of the fish in my home pond have names, so it’s easy to understand how upsetting it can be when one of them becomes a heron’s breakfast special.       

To protect my pond at home, I’ve got one of my dogs, Bandit, on guard duty.  It’s not the most reliable method, but if Bandit sees the heron, he will chase it away.  The problem is that Bandit also likes to sleep under the shade of a mesquite tree at the side of the house or watch people passing by out front.  Both places are out of view of the pond.

There are a few methods that can deter the heron and make things a bit safer for your fish.  You can be sure that your fish have plenty of hiding places.  Pond plants, especially lilies, hornwort and jungle val can keep them out of sight from marauders. One of the ponds at the nursery has a bridge over it and the fish know that they are safe under it.  Another Koi survived a heron feeding frenzy by hiding in an empty bucket that laid on its side at the bottom of the pond.  You can create a hiding spot for your Koi using something similar, a sturdy plastic bucket on its side or cement blocks, and make it look more natural in your pond by covering it with rocks.

Another deterrent is a net.  Stretched across a pond, it will protect your fish, but it does take away from the aesthetics of the pond.  I’ve been told by several sources that a heron statue will keep the real ones away.  I’m not sure about the accuracy of this method, but it may be worth a try.  There is also a device you can purchase called a “scarecrow.”  It attaches to your garden hose and runs on a 9‑volt battery.  It has a motion detector that shoots a blast of water at any thing that moves in front of it. But herons are smart, so if you’re using a statue or a scarecrow, relocate it periodically to throw the heron off guard.

The choice of protection is up to you.  If you don’t mind the look, a net is very effective.  I would choose a combination of methods–plenty of pond plants, a man‑made underwater hiding place and a scarecrow–to keep your prized fish safe.  

Craig Allison is a registered landscape architect with more than 30 years of landscaping and nursery experience.  He previously held positions as a Faculty Associate at Arizona State University’s School of Landscape Architecture and taught design at the Desert Botanical Gardens in Phoenix.  Craig has over 50 published articles and has made appearances on ABC 15’s“Sonoran Living Live” and “Your Life A to Z” on KTVK Ch 3.  He currently owns and manages Carefree Gardens, a retail nursery located at the corner of Carefree Highway and Central Avenue in Desert Hills, and designs for New Garden Design and Landscape, Inc. 

Listen to Craig and call in Sunday mornings from 8 to 9 a.m. starting May 21 on KFNX 1100 AM talk radio.

If you have landscape or garden questions you would like answered, e‑mail your questions to  AskCraig@carefreegardens.net or fax your questions to Carefree Gardens “Ask Craig” at (623) 742‑7216.  Past articles can be found at www.thecarefreegardener.tv.

Back To Real Estate

© 2006 The Desert Advocate
6528 E Cave Creek Rd Ste B | Cave Creek, AZ 85331-8646
480.488.1204 | 480.488.6248 Fax