According
to the Centers for Disease Control, no federal limits
for worker exposure to EMFs have been recommended
or established due to scientific uncertainty. The
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
does not consider EMFs a proven health hazard. Other
government agencies also have refrained from setting
limits or guidelines because EMFs, especially low‑level
fields, have not proven to be a health risk.
However,
because of conflicting data and since the public
continues to be concerned, there are ongoing studies
being conducted by many researchers, including the
World Health Organization.
The
cell tower at Stepping Stones Academy is located
in the middle of the courtyard at the
center of campus. Cricket Communications is the
operator of the tower. The school is located
at 35812 N. 7th Street.
Stephanie
Streett took two of her children out of the school
upon finding out about the cell tower. She said
she was offended not only by how the pole was installed
over the summer without telling parents, but by
school personnel’s “arrogance” and “nastiness” toward
her when she questioned them about it.
“They
told me it was only going to be a flagpole,” Streett
said. “But the pole is about 75 feet tall. So I
asked them, ‘Who are you in competition with, the
White House?’”
Greg
Garbero, whose daughter is in first grade at the
school, works in the telecommunications industry
and said parents who took their children out of
the school are overreacting. “In a perfect world,
we all wish our kids could go to school in some
remote part of Montana.”
Referring
to several studies done on the subject, he said
researchers “have yet to come up with any negative
effects.”
Garbero
also referred The Desert Advocate to several Web
sites indicating cell phone towers pose no known
risks to humans due to the low frequencies they
operate on, enforced by the Federal Communications
Commission and approved by the Food and Drug Administration.
However,
parent Elisabeth Cosgrove was keen to point out
the phrase “known risks.”
“For
years we thought asbestos was safe,” Cosgrove said.
“Even if there’s only a small chance, I can’t take
that chance with my children. Life is too difficult
as it is.”
“I
don’t want to expose my daughter to this 35 hours
a week,” Heidi Cullum said.
Dedre
Alliger, one of the two principals of the charter
school, said when Channel 3 did a story about the
cell tower, a noted neurologist vouched for the
safety of the tower on school grounds.
Alliger
also said she isn’t sure why the school is being
described as deceitful. “We tried to get the information
out in as timely a manner as possible.”
AnnMarie
Short, the school’s other principal, related that
a permit delay on a new building a few years ago
produced the same accusations, prompting the school
to hold off announcing any kind of cell tower project
until the deal was done.
“It
seems like we can’t win,” Short said. “We are truly
saddened people feel this way. That’s not what this
school stands for.”
Alliger
stated the school was preparing its latest newsletter
to announce the cell tower when the first media
reports surfaced and, as a result, they delayed
releasing the newsletter in order to reflect what
had been said on television.
“We
didn’t get the newsletter out as soon as we would’ve
liked,” Alliger said.
Neither
of the principals had an exact figure available
for the number of students removed from the school
last week.
Streett,
though, said she is very unhappy with how the situation
was handled, expressing her frustration over not
being informed the school was considering installation
of a cell phone tower. Streett also said she was
called and asked to support the move, even though
she already had gone on television to speak against
it.
Brenda
Good, mother to a third‑grader, stated she
really has no problem with the cell tower or
the manner in which the school handled the matter.
“The signal goes up; that’s what I always thought.”
Cosgrove
said part of the problem is placement. “If they
had put it in a different place, we probably wouldn’t
be leaving.”
Alliger
noted the pole’s location is by design, not at the
insistence of Cricket.
“I’m
not going to lose any sleep over it; there’s lots
of power lines in that area, and everyone uses a
microwave,” said Sergei Droban, father of two children
at the school. “Besides, I’m talking to you on a
cell phone.”
To
check out the studies cited in this article, go
to www.fda.gov/cellphones/qa.html,
and hps.org/publicinformat‑ion/ate/q79.html.