Dick
cops an absurdist tone to tell the story of an often
absurd, sometimes surreal method whereby an anonymous
panel supposedly representative of the “average
American family” hands out G, PG, PG‑13, R
or NC‑17 ratings, deciding who can and cannot
see certain flicks.
The
director, who made the Academy Award‑nominated
documentary “Twist of Faith,” recounting a man’s
childhood sexual abuse by a priest, approaches the
film with a Michael Moore‑like sense of purpose–though
with a considerably more unassuming attitude.
Like
Moore’s movies, this certainly is not an objective
documentary. Interviews in “This Film Is Not Yet
Rated” are predominantly filled with bemused outrage
and disbelief from edgy filmmakers and daring actors
who have run afoul of the ratings board and critics
who think the system’s a joke.
Matt
Stone (“South Park”) relates how he and filmmaking
partner Trey Parker added outrageous footage they
did not even want to the puppet sex scene in “Team
America: World Police,” hoping they could sneak
less explicit material past the
MPAA.
Maria
Bello and director Wayne Kramer lament the NC‑17
rating their film “The Cooler” received because
of a glimpse of Bello’s pubic hair in a love scene,
while “Scary Movie” earned an R rating despite the
bloody opening sequence in which a woman’s breast
implant is ripped out by a slasher’s knife.
“American
Psycho” director Mary Harron tells how vicious ax
murder and chain‑saw sequences in her movie
passed muster with the MPAA, but a three‑way
sex scene did not.
The
movie incorporates explicit sex clips from many
movies, footage that earned the documentary its
initial NC‑17 rating.
Interspersed
among the interviews are clever animated sequences
that irreverently chide the MPAA and its keepers,
along with amusing segments featuring a private
eye Dick hired to pry into the identities and duties
of ratings board members.
Dick’s
general conclusions echo what MPAA critics have
been saying for decades since the ratings system
came into being in the late 1960s: That filmmakers
are given fuzzy guidance on how to cut films to
receive lower ratings; that the board is lax on
violence and prudish on sex and is tougher on erotic
scenes between same‑sex partners than those
involving a man and woman; that ratings procedures
are secretive and the appeals process inadequate;
and that independent films are rated more harshly
than those from the big studios that formed the
MPAA as its chief trade group.
Dick
submitted an early cut of his film for an MPAA rating,
then added a postscript that gives the documentary
its potent, Kafkaesque climax, in which the director
tries to lift the veil of secrecy on the appeals
process.
The
film is not likely to win many converts to the I
Hate The MPAA Club. Cinephiles who enjoy uncompromising
adult films and abhor gratuitous violence already
are members. The majority of Americans who stick
mainly to generic blockbusters are not going to
lose much sleep if their 16‑year‑old
can’t see “Boys Don’t Cry” the way director Kimberly
Peirce originally intended.
“This
Film Is Not Yet Rated” includes archival footage
of former MPAA boss Jack Valenti doling out his
pat statement that three‑fourths of parents
with young children find the ratings useful.
The
real value of Dick’s film is not in refuting that.
It doesn’t. Rather, it makes the point that apathy,
not support, makes so many people think the ratings
are useful, since the MPAA is the only game in town.
And
it makes a good case for some all‑American
free enterprise to come up with an alternative.
“This
Film Is Not Yet Rated,” an IFC Films release, is
going out unrated after receiving an NC‑17
rating from the MPAA for some graphic sexual content.
Running time: 98 minutes. Three stars out of four.